Splitscreen on Xbox One help [Question] So my gf and I are trying to play through borderlands 2 on split screen. However, when we tried to sign in a 2nd xbox account for player two, it would never load. Borderlands: The Handsome Collection [XBOX ONE] BHC Tech Support. Everytime I attempt to do a split screen co-op, it is telling me that the second player is not signed in and we will be unable to save a new character. BadRobotBlack (Bad Robot Black) April 15, 2015, 11:59pm #1. HELP! I have finally convinced my wife to try Borderlands and because it is backwards compatible with the Xbox One, I've been playing on that.
I have looked high and low for a step-by-step guide for setting up a two-player split screen game on the Xbox One. We cant just use the guest profile because it wont save any data.